Recently, I read two novels that had as their main character an orphan. Both were set in modern times; neither was an adventure or fantasy book. In both cases, the parents were lost in automobile accidents and the main characters were sent to live with eccentric and emotionally unstable relatives. And I found myself thinking about my own upbringing in modern times and how few true orphans seemed to exist. Advances in medicine have pretty much eliminated plagues in developed countries and unless you’re in a war-torn area, your chances of losing both parents in childhood are probably slim. And it got me thinking about all the famous orphans of literature—Jane Eyre, David Copperfield, Huck Finn, Harry Potter, et. al.—and why this is such a popular choice for writers. Wikipedia, as it always does, had an answer:
“The lack of parents leaves the characters to pursue more interesting and adventurous lives, by freeing them from familial obligations and controls, and depriving them of more prosaic lives. It creates characters that are self-contained and introspective and who strive for affection.”
Who writes this stuff? In the case of one of the books I recently read, I felt that the main character’s orphaned status served as an excuse, a crutch. The character was unable to have any type of “normal” life. The writer used the fact of her orphaning as a device to allow the character to act in totally irresponsible and atypical ways. This particular character could not properly relate to any other person; she was a social misfit, a pariah from the rest of the world (a characterization, by the way, I might take offense to if I was an orphan). And it struck me as sort of a lazy characterization ploy, this removing of the parents. Because what’s more difficult, more multi-faceted, more abundant with opportunities for excavation, than the parent-child relationship?
Again, our expert at Wikipedia:
“Parents, furthermore, can be irrelevant to the theme a writer is trying to develop, and orphaning the character frees the writer from the necessity to depict such an irrelevant relationship.”
“Irrelevant relationship?” I’m no psychologist, but I think this Wikipedia contributor may need to explore his relationship with his parents, in therapy.
I’d be interested to hear from writers who have written an orphaned main character and what your reasoning was, what freedoms it gave you in the writing, what drawbacks. Maybe I’ve spent too much time in my books dealing with the ripples of childhood, the influence of parents, and that is why so many of my characters are depressed!